• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Ericas Ed-Ventures

Primary Education Ideas

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Classroom Decor Inspiration
  • Teacher Style
  • Shop
  • Contact

Evidence Binder Completed!!

I have finally finished my evidence binder!   I worked so hard on it, that I decided to tweak it and make it a packet to sell.  Why should you have to reinvent the wheel and make your own dividers, if I already did?   BTW,  I think I bought used just about every Melonheadz clip art set there is involving school or children.   I think it is an awesome looking packet – if I do say so myself!

If you don’t know what an evidence binder is, be glad!  Just kidding…well not really.  The evidence binder is part of APPR, a teacher evaluation system adapted by NY State and probably a lot of other states.  Our district chose the Danielson Framework for Teaching.  Teachers are assessed based on a point system and the evidence binder is part of that point system.  I am no expert on the Framework or  APPR.  I really just do what I need to do.   The evidence binder itself is supposed to include “evidence” that you were a “highly effective” teacher.  There are four domains: Domain One – Planning and Preparation,  Domain Two – The Classroom Environment, Domain Three – Instruction, and Domain Four – Reflecting on Teaching.  Each domain has subcategories.  Each district has different requirements for what exactly goes into their teachers’ evidence binders.

In this packet, I included dividers for the four domains, dividers for the sub-categories, an editable binder cover,  binder spine inserts, evidence logs, editable evidence logs, and samples from my evidence binder with links for the evidence I utilized.

 Click the image below to check out this packet on TpT:

Here is a sample of one piece of evidence and the evidence log:

I have been reading some of the comments on this post and I totally agree that this was a waste of my valuable time.  It took me forever to finish.  It is a nice way for our administrators to see what we are doing in our room, but on the other hand, the administrators would have more time to come into our rooms or walk around the building if they did not have to spend hours writing up observations.  The new observation format is crazy!  It makes me never want to be an administrator.

Filed Under: Evidence Binder, Uncategorized

Previous Post: « A Peek at a Mish Mosh of a Week – April 29th
Next Post: The Big TpT SALE – Early Bird Special »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Jen L

    May 5, 2013 at 2:55 am

    WOW! Amazing work! I have a feeling something like this is coming my way soon! Thanks for making this a packet!

  2. Special Teacher for Special Kids

    May 5, 2013 at 3:02 am

    Wow, Erica this looks great. I just had dinner tonight with my brother and sister in law and this was the topic of conversation.

    My brother in law had to hand his in on Friday (Nassau County School District). Nothing as pretty as yours. I know all about this binder! I am not looking forward to having to do this, just yet. I am in NYC.

    Thanks for sharing it. The domain blurb is that from the framework or something you re-wrote.

    Iteachkidsabc@gmail.com
    :o) V.
    Special Teacher for Special Kids

    • Erica Bohrer

      May 5, 2013 at 3:06 am

      I just wrote what I understand it to be. The actual domains are specific and part of the framework. So I just wrote what they are. For example, Domain One is called Planning and Preparation.

  3. dbednars

    May 5, 2013 at 3:05 am

    We use Danielson also. The binder took countless hrs. These dividers are awesome. Mine were boring compared to these.

  4. Deirdre

    May 5, 2013 at 3:15 am

    Way to go! I live in MA and our system is a bit different, but equally exhausting. What a big job you accomplished.
    Deirdre
    A Burst of First

  5. Erica

    May 5, 2013 at 3:15 am

    I would just like to mention how ridiculous it is that you have to show "proof" that you're a highly effective teacher. I'd bet we could be even more highly effective if we weren't wasting time proving we are highly effective!!! (And I'm sure they could read your blog and find that out for themselves!)

    That little rant aside, your binder looks awesome. I can tell you put a LOT of work into it, and I hope that it pays off! I'm not looking forward to the day when I have to do this same thing! Right now, our school has to do a "program review" where we have to show evidence as a school that we're teaching certain areas (Arts and Humanities, Writing, and Practical Living right now). We have 3 big crates we have to fill with our evidence and a write up on what we did. That's nothing compared to the work you did!

    Erica
    Blooming In First

  6. CarolP

    May 5, 2013 at 3:23 am

    The binder looks great, but I agree that is totally crazy that you had to provide this evidence! I'm sure it took away countless hours that could have been used on preparing lessons or doing something that would have provided rest to you so you were prepared to teach!!! I sure hope this doesn't come to California! Carol

  7. Pam

    May 5, 2013 at 3:27 am

    Looks awesome!!! I will definitely be using these next year for documentation for my evaluation!!!!

  8. A. Monroe

    May 5, 2013 at 3:29 am

    Wow! This looks like a massive amount of work. Thanks you so much for sharing. I'll be sure to check it out.

    School Is a Happy Place

  9. Simply Bibi

    May 5, 2013 at 4:06 am

    I teach in NJ and we use the Danielson Framework as well. We haven't been asked to provide an evidence binder YET, but I'm pretty sure that's coming down the pike. Thank you for creating and sharing! This will help me get a leg up on what I could tell is hours of paperwork! You're awesome 🙂

    Vivian

  10. Christy

    May 5, 2013 at 6:13 am

    Wow! I know WA is changing teacher evaluations next year, but I have no idea what it will look like. Thanks for creating this. It's good to know that there are resources out there like this one 🙂

    ~Christy
    Mrs. Holder’s First Grade

  11. Jenna B

    May 5, 2013 at 6:19 am

    Our district is doing a pilot on the Danielson Framework for our state. Not loving it! But I love your binder! Definitely putting it on my wish list!!!

  12. Julia Fuchs

    May 5, 2013 at 12:07 pm

    Thank you so, so much!!! This product is amazing!!! This NY teacher is right there with you….using Danielson and struggling to find the balance of time spent on what makes one an effective (or hopefully highly effective) teacher….and time spent on what goes into proving it. Thank you for putting countless hours into something that will help countless other teachers in NY and beyond :)!!!!!

  13. Karen Day

    May 5, 2013 at 1:03 pm

    We are changing teacher evaluations this year. This is going on my wishlist until we find out what is needed. I can see where this change over is going to be a nightmare!! I am excited that this binder might make my life easier (and cuter!)

  14. Mrs. McHaffie

    May 5, 2013 at 1:58 pm

    We have a similar evaluation plan except we do not have to show evidence, HOWEVER, this is such a great way to organize and to self reflect! Love this!! The adorable clipart is a bonus! 🙂

    Kelly
    Beg, Borrow, Steal

  15. Julia Fuchs

    May 5, 2013 at 6:37 pm

    Agree….I had (a few years back) requested materials from local SUNY schools for degrees in admin. NO WAY would I consider it the way things are right now. So sad:(. It's alright though, I'm sure I'm much happier with the kiddos anyway!!

  16. Comincioli

    May 5, 2013 at 8:25 pm

    We are also using the Danielson Framework for our evaluations but our district isn't requiring us to create an evidence binder yet. Next year we will be going through Saphier Training while we are writing our Math Common Core Units and rewriting/updating our ELA Common Core Units, along with the extensive lessons we have to create for evaluations. If we have to do the binders, I will definitely be using this!! Thanks for creating it!

    Carrie
    Table Talk with C & C

  17. Bridget S

    May 5, 2013 at 8:28 pm

    We are evaluated based on Danielson's Framework, but do not have to have an evidence binder. This is a fantastic resource that will help so many teachers!!!!

    Bridget
    Literacy Without Worksheets

  18. Ashley

    May 5, 2013 at 9:15 pm

    Erica, You are just the best. It is in my cart. I live in Illinois and we also adopted the same framework. Thanks for all your time and effort and sharing it with us!
    Ashley

  19. Miss Ice

    May 5, 2013 at 11:10 pm

    I also live in IL and we adopted this framework and its going into affect next year. They keep talking about how we will have to put all of our evidence onto this website. I'm wondering if it would be helpful to have hard copies in a binder as well. I'm definitely wish listing this until I get an answer. Thanks!

    Courtney
    3rd Grade Sprinkles

  20. Lisa

    May 5, 2013 at 11:25 pm

    I teach in PA. I hear that we are going to be changing next year, but have not heard any details. We are still not even implementing CC in my district. I fear that all of this will happen at once. I'm at 30 years…maybe this will all nudge me towards retirement. Sigh.

    • Erica Bohrer

      May 6, 2013 at 12:08 am

      It is so sad but many teachers who were not thinking of retirement are now. Honestly, if I were married and had health benefits, I would do TpT full time. So, sad that government is taking the joy out of teaching and causing us to have maxed out classes.

  21. Erika

    May 6, 2013 at 12:31 am

    We will be using Danielson in my district next year! I have used it in a different district too.

    Erika
    My Crazy Life

  22. Kiki

    May 6, 2013 at 6:26 am

    Wow, I had no idea this was something going on in other states. California only has new teacher support where we fill out a binder much like this one..but during your first two years of teaching, not each year. What an immense amount of time– I wish there was a happy medium between trusting teachers and holding them accountable…this seems to be an extreme. Looks beautiful though!

  23. Christin W

    May 6, 2013 at 5:13 pm

    Wow! This loks amazing! Congrats on finishing. Our county in VA has adopted a similar things called a Professional Growth Portfolio. I have my meeting on Thursday to review it with my principal. We shall see how it goes.

    Christin
    http://www.shiftingteacherk-2.blogspot.com

  24. 1st grade tcr

    May 8, 2013 at 9:38 pm

    I only wish I had seen this 2 weeks ago!!!! I turned mine in last week – but it was nothing like this. I am buying it tonight to have for next year. This way I can start in September and not panic. Thanks for all you hard work. It looks amazing.

  25. Monique Ralston

    July 4, 2013 at 2:36 am

    Hello Erica,
    My school district will implement the Danielson Framework model for the 2014-2015 school year. So this upcoming school year my co-workers and I have decided to get ahead start. This is a BIG HELP!!! Thanks a lot its on my wish list.

  26. Vic Vale

    March 31, 2014 at 3:32 am

    How much Non-instructional time do you get? It seems like an enormous amount of work! I have recently left a full time class room role for a part time specialist role as the workload just keeps increasing (and I taught 5 yr old's with no support – exhausting!).
    Too many meetings, too much admin and too many demanding and neurotic parents!
    Rant over….. Sorry….
    I am sure there are many grateful teachers out there now that you have developed such a comprehensive package. I have always found your TPT pkgs so very helpful in reducing my prep time! You are an inspiration xx

Primary Sidebar

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Search

Categories

Subscribe via Email

Featured Products

Disclosure: This website/blog contains affiliate links.  What that means is that when you click on a link to a merchant and purchase something, I get a small percentage of the sale at no additional cost to you.

Footer

Latest on Instagram

Cute Amazon teacher bracelets! I actually receive Cute Amazon teacher bracelets!  I actually received the Mrs. B one from a sweet student. 

Want the link?  Comment AMAZON below. 

#amazonfashionfinds #teachersfollowteachers #teacherstyle #amazonfashion
Create a student portfolio with banners! Start wi Create a student portfolio with banners!  Start with day one and save your display banners throughout the year to create a keepsake of the year for each student. 
The banners are print and go and some are Freebies in my store.  You could also grab the bundle and be set for the whole year! 

Want the links?  Comment “banners” below and I will DM you the link. 

#firstgradeteacher #studentwriting #teacherspayteachers
Teacher Tip: Keep ready made reminder slips and “t Teacher Tip: Keep ready made reminder slips and “to do” notes on your desk for easy access.

This saves you time and energy and just a bit more organized.

Want the link?  Comment “slips” below and I will DM you.

#teachertips #teacherhacks #classroomorganization #teachersfollowteachers
Do you have students who struggle with number sens Do you have students who struggle with number sense?  I have a free visual number path for you.  Want the link?  Comment “number path” below and I will dm you the link.

#numberpath #eurekamath #firstgrademath #teacherfreebies
Probably a little late to this Kinda Chic trend bu Probably a little late to this Kinda Chic trend but I am old 😂.
Yes, I still dress up everyday.  I only wear sneakers on dress down days or for field trips, but I am not going to judge you for what you wear.  I have seen teachers running after kids, so I get wearing sneakers to work.  I love shopping, plus dresses are just more flattering and easier for me to wear.

I have always had a very organized and clearly labeled classroom.  That is my calm.  Some FB ladies have said it is too busy but it works for me.  I have never seen a kid getting distracted by it, there is so much more to distract them…like other kids.

I started small group weight training classes @elevationfitnessli in March of 2025 and have been going regularly.  I enjoy meeting and becoming friendly with the other teachers at our 4:30 classes.  I also love that I can see physical changes as well.  Pull-ups are so hard but I am proud of my progress.

I still love teaching after 24 years.  I don’t love how it has become harder than it was when I started (bigger class sizes, more behaviors, more curriculum to cover, etc.) but I still love connecting with my students and helping them grow.  We can retire at 55 years old, as a tier 4 teacher, and I think I will be ready then to go.  I am lucky that I have been able to stay in the same grade for almost all of those 24 years!

I have been a TpT seller since 2008 and a blogger since 2011!  Thank you all who have been with me over the years and welcome new teacher friends!

#kindachic
The first few weeks of school are all about modeli The first few weeks of school are all about modeling and practicing routines.  These are routines that will be reinforced all year long.  We can’t expect students to know how we expect them to do things, even simple things like walking in the hall without explicit instruction. 
🏫I teach my students to walk on the third tile from the wall when in line.  1. This gives them something to concentrate on while walking.  2. This keeps their hands off the walls.  This keeps their hands away from artwork and away from germs.  If you are a teacher you know first hand what students can do to walls 😂.
My students earn incentives for compliments from other teachers about their behavior.  They are so proud when they earn. *Of course, if you have students with special needs you would not expect everyone to walk on the third tile. Teachers know their students and what they are capable of.
F R E E Friday! 🚌My students love morning meeting F R E E  Friday! 🚌My students love morning meetings, I love morning meetings, and subs love them, too.  I have weekly themed meetings slides that I use throughout the year.  You can easily edit them or add to them.  When I am absent, I add my phonics, writing, and math slides to them to make it easier for a sub to get through the day. 
🏫You can grab a free sample slide set for the first day of school by commenting BTS below. 

#freefriday #teacherfreebies #morningmeeting #firstgradeteacher #backtoschool
Follow on Instagram

Copyright © 2026 · Website Design By Jumping Jax Designs